
Absence, wellbeing and the gap between what pupils and staff see
What a new NFER study of ten secondary schools tells us about why pupils are still missing schoolPersistent absence in England’s secondary schools has not returned to where it was before the pandemic, and there is little sign that it is about to. Absence rates doubled from 13.7 per cent of secondary pupils in 2018/19 to 27.7 per cent in 2021/22. By 2024/25 the figure had eased back to 23.4 per cent, which still means that close to one pupil in four misses at least ten per cent of sessions.
Plenty of research has counted the problem. Rather less has asked the people living it. A new NFER study, funded by the Nuffield Foundation, sets out to do exactly that by putting the views of school staff, pupils, and parents and carers side by side in the same schools.
How the study was done
The researchers grouped English secondary schools by how their absence rates had moved from before the pandemic to after it: those that held steady, those that rose and then began to fall, and those that rose and stayed high. Ten schools agreed to take part, spread across the three groups.
In each school the team gathered:
- interviews with senior leaders and attendance staff (12 staff in total)
- interviews with pupils who had been persistently absent and had returned, or were returning
- a focus group with pupils who had not been persistently absent (62 pupils took part across interviews and focus groups)
- interviews with 14 parents and carers
- a survey completed by 399 parents and carers
Two caveats worth holding in mind. Schools and families who volunteer for research of this kind tend to be the more engaged ones, and the study deliberately focused on pupils who had come back, so it says less about those who never did. Almost two-thirds of the survey responses also came from a single school, though weighting the results suggested that school was not skewing the picture.
Wellbeing is seen as a major driver, but staff are divided on why
Ask parents and carers why absence has risen and wellbeing comes near the top. Just over half (51 per cent) named poor pupil mental health or wellbeing as a main reason, second only to the rising cost of holidays outside term time (52 per cent). Asked why wellbeing itself has declined, two-thirds pointed to mobile phones and social media.
School staff were less united. Some described a real deterioration, reporting more pupils presenting with symptoms of anxiety and depression, less resilience in the face of an ordinary school day, and long waits for specialist help. Others suspected they were seeing better detection rather than more illness: if you train staff to notice and pupils to speak up, referrals rise whether or not the underlying rate has moved. A small number went further and felt that everyday stress was sometimes being treated as a medical reason not to attend.
Pupils see absence for poor mental health as legitimate
Among the pupils interviewed there was broad agreement that poor mental health justifies a day off in much the same way a fever does. They described school as tiring and, at times, overwhelming: tests, homework, exam pressure, friendship trouble, bullying. Time away was framed as recovery.
Parents and carers were close to this position without fully sharing it. A third said missing school for poor mental health was acceptable and a further 39 per cent said it was sometimes acceptable, roughly the same proportions as for a long-term condition such as asthma or diabetes. At the same time, 87 per cent agreed it was important their child attended every day.
The relationship runs in both directions
Everyone agreed wellbeing and attendance are connected. What the study adds is how the connection works, and it is not a one-way street.
Poor wellbeing makes attending harder: early starts, long journeys, crowded corridors, noisy dining halls, being asked to speak in class. But absence then creates its own problems. Pupils described relief at first, followed by anxiety about the work piling up, worry about test results, loneliness, and lost friendships. Several said the hardest part of going back was the questions from classmates about where they had been.
Time away protects wellbeing in the short term and undermines the ability to return in the long term.
The reinforcing cycle described by pupils and staff alike
Staff tended to emphasise the other side of the ledger: routine, learning, friendships, and time away from a phone. Interestingly, pupils partly agreed, noting that school suited those doing well academically and could be a refuge from a difficult home. The divergence is less about facts than about which effects each group sees most of.
Absence is about much more than wellbeing
The report groups the drivers into four intersecting levels: the pupil (mental health, SEND, confidence, physical health, transition into Year 7), the school (environment, staff capacity, lack of specialist provision), home and family (parental attitudes, routines, financial hardship), and the wider system (external services, community factors, confusion about what counts as a legitimate absence).
Staff repeatedly named term-time holidays, mild illness and unmet SEND needs alongside wellbeing. One leader described the pre-pandemic understanding between schools and families as broken, with attendance now treated as closer to optional. Nothing here points to a single lever.
Bullying may be the most underestimated factor
This is one of the study’s sharper findings. Bullying came up again and again among persistently absent pupils and their parents, sometimes involving conduct that continued beyond the school gates and online, and sometimes with families feeling the school had not acted decisively. Pupils wanted tougher consequences and said existing sanctions were treated as a joke by those receiving them.
Yet bullying was not a prominent theme in the staff interviews. Friendship difficulties were mentioned; bullying as a driver of absence was not. The sample is small, so this cannot be pushed too far, but the mismatch suggests schools may be underrating how often absence traces back to a pupil not feeling safe.
What schools are doing, and what actually lands
Every case study school had staff with dedicated attendance responsibilities, and most ran two parallel tracks. The first is a formal compliance pathway: monitoring, letters, structured meetings, improvement plans, home visits, and ultimately penalty notices. The second is a support pathway: part-time timetables and phased returns, adjusted start and finish times, access to quiet or dedicated spaces, changes to subject choices, counselling and mentoring, home visits to rebuild trust, and referrals to CAMHS or local authority services. In one school, staff collected pupils by minibus.
The two tracks often ran at once, and the balance between them varied. Where staff read low-level distress as something a pupil needed to push through, the response leaned towards compliance. Where they read it as unmet need, it leaned towards support.
What pupils and families valued most was not a named intervention. It was being taken seriously: staff who checked in without making a scene, who treated concerns about bullying or fatigue or uniform as real, who listened to parents rather than lecturing them, and who then flexed something concrete to make the day manageable.
The complaints were the mirror image. Support that arrived only after repeated advocacy. Timetable adjustments withdrawn without explanation. No work sent home during absence and no catch-up on return. And, in a few cases, pupils parked in a small internal unit for most of the day, physically present but cut off from teaching and from friends. A physical return, the report notes, is not the same as reintegration.
Fines are the one thing almost nobody defended
Penalty notices drew consistent criticism from every group. Seventy per cent of parents and carers surveyed rated them not very or not at all helpful. Parents of persistently absent pupils described the threat of a fine as an extra source of anxiety for a child already struggling, and pointed out that it does nothing about the reason for the absence.
Staff were often reluctant to trigger them, on the grounds that the families most affected are frequently the poorest, and that a fine compounds the problem. For holidays, the arithmetic simply does not bite, as one leader put it: fines are “pointless for most” when the saving on a term-time holiday dwarfs the penalty.
Staff also flagged a policy tension. Schools are being asked to build pupils’ sense of belonging and stronger relationships with families, and in the same breath to send out threatening letters about fines.
What parents did want was mental health support in secondary schools (80 per cent thought it would help), breakfast clubs (69 per cent), and above all measures that help pupils feel safe in school (83 per cent) and improve relationships between pupils (79 per cent).
What the report asks for
For schools:
- approach persistent absence with curiosity rather than suspicion, and invest in trusted relationships with pupils and families
- keep building resilience through classroom and individual work alongside curriculum delivery
- treat bullying, in school and online, as a live attendance issue and keep the environment safe and inclusive
- give real attention to the primary-to-secondary transition, including friendships and familiarity with the building
For government:
- resource the services outside school, from local authorities to family support to mental health provision, that schools depend on
- fund attendance staff and interventions properly, since recent policy added workload without money
- invest in mainstream infrastructure so buildings and provision fit a more diverse range of needs
- monitor the effect of the under-16 social media restrictions, expected by spring 2027, on online bullying and absence
- re-examine fines, and whether they cut against the push for belonging
- look at how the Schools’ White Paper, the curriculum review and social media restrictions interact
The takeaway
The most useful thing in this report is not a number. It is the discovery that pupils, parents and staff are looking at the same problem and describing different things. Pupils see school as a source of pressure that sometimes has to be escaped. Staff see attendance as the route through which most problems get solved. Parents are caught between the two, wanting their child in school and watching them struggle there.
Absence policy that only addresses one of those views will keep missing. This is an interim report, with findings from linked administrative data and international policy comparison still to come, but the direction is already clear enough: attendance is not going to be fixed by pressure applied to families alone.
The full report is available from NFER at nfer.ac.uk.